The condo at Paraiso Del Mar Resort was so great! My husband and I rented this condo along with two other couples and it was exactly what the doctor ordered. Each couple had their own bedroom, terrace and bathroom. The pictures did not even do the place justice! Getting to the condos via Boat Shuttle was a bit confusing the first day, but once we figured the boat taxi out, it was easy! I really enjoyed being away from town, it felt really exclusive.
We honestly felt like we rented out the whole place, we didn't see that many people. Go to eat at the Rancho Viejo (I think I spelled it right). It is 2 blocks from where the boat taxi drops you off and its so good! The Nachos Asada are Amazing! I have already recommended this place to a few others and I just got back! It was very low key and not tourist-y, which is exactly what I love :) The water was beautiful, we kayaked out to some dolphins our last day which was the cherry on top!